Bought Pro? It is on your account. Sign in

Guide

Contractor vs employee: which agreement do you need?

Short answer

If you control how, when and where someone works, pay them a salary and integrate them into your team, they are probably an employee and need an offer letter and employment contract. If they run their own business, choose their methods and carry their own risk, a consulting or services agreement fits. The label in the contract does not decide status; the reality does.

By ยท Updated

A drafting aid, not legal advice. Templates are a starting point and laws change. Have a qualified lawyer review your document before you sign it or rely on it.

The factors that decide status

Factors pointing to employment or to an independent contractor
FactorPoints to employeePoints to contractor
ControlYou decide how, when and where the work is doneThey decide methods and schedule; you set objectives
HoursFixed working hoursHours set by the project or their own choice
ExclusivityWorks only for youFree to work for other clients
Financial riskSalary regardless of resultsFixed fees or rates; bears own costs; can make a loss
Tools and equipmentProvided by youTheir own
SubstitutionMust do the work personallyCan send someone else or subcontract
IntegrationPart of your team, org chart, internal toolsOutside your organisation
BenefitsLeave, pension, health insuranceNone from you

How the UAE, UK and US decide

  • UAE: employees are hired under the Labour Law (Federal Decree-Law No. 33 of 2021) with an employer-sponsored visa and work permit, probation, notice and end-of-service gratuity. A contractor needs its own trade licence or freelance permit. Someone working full time under your direction without either is a compliance problem, not a contractor.
  • UK: there are three statuses: employee, worker and self-employed, each with different rights. If a contractor works through their own company, the off-payroll (IR35) rules apply, and medium and large clients must make the status determination.
  • US: the IRS looks at behavioural control, financial control and the type of relationship. Some states, including California, use the stricter ABC test, under which a worker is an employee unless they are free from control, do work outside the usual course of your business and are in an independently established trade.

Which Legal Drafter template to use

Matching the relationship to a template
RelationshipTemplateKey clauses
Employee joining your companyEmployment offer letterProbation, notice, salary, conditions; UAE gratuity, UK pension, US at-will
Adviser, fractional executive, consultantConsulting agreementStatus, conflicts, work product, optional restrictions
Freelancer or agency delivering a projectFreelance services agreementScope, revisions, deposit, IP on payment
Developer building softwareSoftware development agreement (Pro)Milestones, acceptance, source code handover

Both contractor templates include a clause confirming independent status and making the contractor responsible for its own tax, licences and permits. That clause supports the relationship you intend, but it cannot change the facts if the person in practice works like an employee.

FAQ

Can I convert a contractor into an employee?

Yes. End the contractor agreement on its notice terms and make an employment offer. The offer letter template includes contractor-to-employee conversions as a use case.

What happens if I misclassify someone?

Depending on the country, you may owe back taxes, social contributions, holiday pay or gratuity, and penalties. Take advice if a long-term contractor works like a member of staff.

Is a consultant on a monthly retainer an employee?

Not because of the retainer alone. What matters is control, integration, exclusivity and who bears the business risk.

Templates for this

Draft any of them with a guided form; party details stay in your browser.