Comparison
Spreadsheet or proposal tracker? An honest comparison
Short answer
A spreadsheet is enough if you send a few proposals a month and enjoy building formulas. A tracker saves time once you bid weekly: it scores each job before you bid, turns bid units into money, keeps dated status history and draws the charts for you. BidBoard exports everything to CSV, so you can always go back to a spreadsheet.
Side by side
| Spreadsheet | BidBoard | |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | Design your own columns and formulas | Ready to use, no account needed to try it |
| Fit check before bidding | Possible with formulas you write | Five-point score, live as you fill the form |
| Real cost per proposal | A formula per row | Bid units × your unit cost, stored per lead |
| Status history with dates | Manual, easy to overwrite | Every move saved with its date and time |
| Charts | You build and maintain them | Win rate, cost per win, spend by month, outcomes by fit and freshness |
| Proposal drafts | None | Short AI first drafts, built to use only your saved portfolio facts |
| Follow-ups | Sort by a date column | A “Follow-ups due” list on the board |
| Price | Free | Free for up to 15 active leads; Pro $5 for 30 days |
| Your data | Your file | This browser, or your account if you sign in; CSV export any time |
When a spreadsheet is the better choice
- You send only a handful of proposals a month.
- You want columns BidBoard does not have, or you already have a system you like.
- You never want to use AI for drafts.
When a tracker saves time
- You bid weekly and want to stop spending on jobs that rarely answer.
- You want cost per win and outcomes by fit score without building charts.
- You want a draft to edit instead of a blank page, built to use only your own work.
Moving between the two
Settings → Export CSV gives every lead with its status history, money as plain decimals and your notes, ready for any spreadsheet. BidBoard never connects to a freelance platform. You add each lead by hand or by pasting the job post, which keeps you inside every platform’s terms.
Track your own proposals. BidBoard is free for up to 15 active leads, with no sign-up to try. Not affiliated with any freelance platform.
Questions
Can I import a spreadsheet into BidBoard?
Not yet. You can export all leads to CSV at any time, and the data you entered without an account can be moved into your account when you sign in.
Is BidBoard free?
Yes, for up to 15 active leads and 1 AI draft a day (up to 30 a month) with a free account. Pro is $5 for 30 days for unlimited leads and up to 25 AI drafts a day, within a shared daily AI budget.
Where is my data stored?
Without an account, in your browser only. Signed in, in your mumshadjawad.com account. The owner sees only totals, never your leads.