Website security checks: what SiteShield tests and how to fix each one

Short answer

SiteShield runs 17 passive checks in 5 groups: encryption, browser protection, server hygiene, email spoofing and domain. Each check is worth a fixed number of points (HTTPS 30, DMARC 12, HSTS, CSP, the redirect and vulnerable libraries 10 each). A fail loses the full points, a warning half, and the remaining score maps to a grade from A to F.

17 checksBy Mumshad JawadUpdated

All 17 checks

Each check links to a guide that explains it in plain English, shows the exact pass/warn/fail rule, and gives copy-paste fixes for Cloudflare, Nginx, Apache and WordPress (or your DNS host, for the email and domain checks).

Encryption

CheckPointsWhy it matters
Site loads over HTTPS30Without HTTPS, anything visitors type (logins, contact forms, card details) travels in plain text and can be read or changed on public Wi-Fi.
http:// redirects to https://10Visitors who type your address without https:// land on an unencrypted page first, which an attacker on the same network can hijack.
HSTS (Strict-Transport-Security)10HSTS tells browsers to never load your site over plain HTTP again, closing the gap that the first redirect leaves open.

Browser protection

CheckPointsWhy it matters
Content-Security-Policy10A CSP limits which scripts can run on your pages. It is the main defence against cross-site scripting and card-skimming scripts (Magecart).
Clickjacking protection5Without it, another site can load yours in an invisible frame and trick visitors into clicking buttons they can't see.
X-Content-Type-Options3Stops browsers from guessing file types, which attackers can abuse to run uploaded files as scripts.
Referrer-Policy2Controls how much of your page URLs (which can contain tokens or customer IDs) leak to other sites when visitors click links.
Permissions-Policy2Switches off browser features your site doesn't use (camera, microphone, location), so an injected script can't use them either.

Server hygiene

CheckPointsWhy it matters
Software versions hidden3Advertising exact server or framework versions lets attackers look up known exploits for that version in seconds.
Cookie security flags5Cookies without Secure can leak over HTTP; without HttpOnly, any injected script can steal sessions; without SameSite, other sites can make requests as your logged-in users.
No mixed content5Loading scripts, images or styles over http:// on an https:// page breaks the padlock and lets attackers swap those files.
No known-vulnerable JavaScript libraries10Old versions of popular libraries have published exploits. Automated bots scan for them constantly.

Email spoofing

CheckPointsWhy it matters
SPF record8SPF lists the servers allowed to send email for your domain. Without it, anyone can send email that looks like it came from you.
DMARC policy12DMARC tells Gmail, Outlook and others to reject email that fakes your domain. Without it, criminals can send invoices or payment requests 'from' your CEO or finance team.

Domain

CheckPointsWhy it matters
DNSSEC2DNSSEC signs your DNS records so attackers can't redirect your visitors to a fake copy of your site by poisoning DNS.
CAA record2A CAA record limits which certificate authorities may issue certificates for your domain, making fake certificates harder to obtain.
security.txt1A security.txt file tells researchers how to report a vulnerability to you privately, instead of posting it publicly.

Points add up to 120, more than 100, so a site with many failures bottoms out at 0 rather than going negative.

How the A–F grade is calculated

  1. The score starts at 100.
  2. A fail subtracts the check's full points; a warning subtracts half, rounded up. Passed and not-checked results cost nothing.
  3. If the homepage doesn't load over HTTPS, the score is capped at 40 and the checks that need a secure page are marked Not checked.
  4. The final score maps to a grade:
GradeScore
A90–100
B80–89
C65–79
D50–64
F0–49

Worked example: a site that passes everything except DMARC at p=none (warning, −6), no DNSSEC (warning, −1) and no security.txt (warning, −1) scores 92, grade A. The same site with no DMARC record at all (fail, −12) and no CAA record (warning, −1) scores 85, grade B.

What the scanner does (and doesn't do)

A scan is deliberately passive, so it's safe to run on any site you're responsible for:

  • One GET https://yourdomain/, following redirects, to read the response headers, cookies and homepage HTML (first 400 KB).
  • One GET http://yourdomain/ without following the redirect, to see where plain HTTP sends visitors.
  • One request for /.well-known/security.txt.
  • Public DNS lookups (TXT, _dmarc TXT, MX, CAA, A) through Cloudflare's DNS-over-HTTPS resolver.

It doesn't log in, submit forms, guess hidden URLs or scan ports, and it isn't a penetration test. Results for a domain are cached for one hour. The scanner identifies itself with the user agent SiteShieldBot/1.0.

FAQ

How is the SiteShield security score calculated?

Every scan starts at 100. A failed check loses its full points and a warning loses half, rounded up. The grade is A at 90 or more, B at 80, C at 65, D at 50 and F below 50. If the homepage doesn't load over HTTPS the score is capped at 40 (grade F).

Does SiteShield hack or stress-test my website?

No. It makes the same requests a visitor's browser and a mail server make: one homepage load over HTTPS, one plain http:// request that isn't followed, a request for /.well-known/security.txt, and public DNS lookups. It never guesses hidden paths, submits forms or tries passwords.

Why do email checks affect a website grade?

SPF and DMARC live in the same DNS as your website and protect the same domain name. A domain anyone can send email from is a business risk (fake invoices, payment fraud) even if the website itself is perfect.

What does Not checked mean?

The check couldn't run: usually because the site didn't load over HTTPS (so there were no headers or cookies to read) or a DNS lookup failed. Not checked costs no points.

Get your grade in 30 seconds

Run all 17 checks on your website and email domain in about 30 seconds. Free, no signup, passive checks only.

Rather not do it yourself? Fix it for me starts at AED 750 (about USD 205 by PayPal), quote agreed first. Monitoring re-scans weekly for AED 99/month or AED 990/year.